| Year | Winner | Tournament | Species | Measurement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Greg Taylor | Yearlong | Striped bass | 46 inches |
| Mark Celio | Yearlong | Bluefish | 34.5 inches | |
| Paul Leclerc | Yearlong | Striped bass, flyrod | 30 inches | |
| Vuth Phok Kevin Stone Matt Austin Bob Baker | NV4M Challenge | Bass + bluefish + false albacore | 71 inches, combined | |
| 2022 | Charlie Lepre | Yearlong | Striped bass | 46.5 inches |
| Luke Znosko | Yearlong | Bluefish | 14 pounds | |
| Michael Lynch | Fall Run Classic | Striped bass | 35 inches | |
| Team 2: Rich Heffernan Richie Reich Jim Harper Henri Lanciaux | NV4M Challenge | Bass + bluefish + false albacore | 101.5 inches, combined | |
| 2021 | Charlie Lepre | Yearlong | Striped bass | 47.25 inches |
| Luke Znosko | Yearlong | Bluefish | 18 pounds | |
| Team 4: Ron Lynch Joe McCoy Gene Spring Marty Wencek | NV4M Challenge | Bass + bluefish | 51.5 inches, combined | |
| Luke Znosko | Spring Run Classic | Striped bass | 40 inches | |
| 2020 | Luke Znosko | Yearlong | Striped bass | 39 inches |
| Mike Lynch | Yearlong | Bluefish | 7.54 pounds | |
| Luke Znosko | Fall Run Classic | Striped bass | 36 inches | |
| 2019 | Glenn St. Germain | Yearlong | Striped bass | 38 inches |
| 2018 | Ed Sousa | Yearlong | Striped bass | 44 inches |
| 2017 | Ed Sousa | Yearlong | Striped bass | 44 inches |
| 2016 | Ed Sousa | Yearlong | Striped bass | 48 inches |
| 2015 | Ed Sousa | Yearlong | Striped bass | 49 inches |
| 2014 | Tom McGuire | Yearlong | Striped bass | 29 pounds, 8 oz |
| 2013 | Richard Reich | Yearlong | Striped bass | 51 pounds, 0.7 oz |
| 2012 | Tom McGuire | Yearlong | Striped bass | 27 pounds, 9 oz |
| 2011 | Tom McGuire | Yearlong | Striped bass | 25 pounds, 8 oz |
| 2010 | Curtis Bruno | Yearlong | Striped bass | 36.2 pounds |
| 2009 | Brendan Richards | Yearlong | Striped bass | 37.3 pounds |
| 2008 | Michael Dunphy | Yearlong | Striped bass | 34.12 pounds |
| 2007 | Tyler Rhoads | Yearlong | Striped bass | 37.32 pounds |
| 2006 | Tom McGuire | Yearlong | Striped bass | 35.84 pounds |